Collaboration & Trust |
Transforming Leadership

Collaborative leadership is the ability to lead people with different backgrounds and differing opinions toward a shared goal, built on the recognition that no single leader holds every answer. It rests on humility, genuine curiosity about what others know, and the capacity to build the trust and structure that let people work together over time, not only in a moment of crisis.

This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen, in which he writes: "The dilemma encountered by collaborative leadership is how to enable people with diverse opinions to take part in realizing and creating a common goal."

Why It Sounds Simple and Turns Out to Be Hard

Most managers agree, in principle, that collaboration is worthwhile. Few actually practice it. A study on the traits that make it hard for leaders to adopt a collaborative style found five recurring factors: a hunger for power, managerial arrogance, a defensive approach, fear of failure, and a big ego. Surprisingly, a big ego turned out to be the factor with the least impact of the five. Arrogance, by contrast, ranks as the central barrier: a leader who walks into the room assuming he already possesses the best answer is fundamentally less attentive to others, and simply doesn't listen closely enough to discover that a better answer might exist. An article published a few years ago in the Wall Street Journal, titled "The Best Bosses Are Humble Bosses," coined a precise term for this: the H Factor, a combination of honesty and humility. The trouble is that most of our familiar images of strong leadership are still built on confidence and having all the answers, not on humility, curiosity, and learning.

Humility as a Source of Strength, Not Weakness

In the organizational world, the opposite belief still prevails: that a good leader is one who can give a fast, confident answer to any question. But in the most extreme situations, when no known solution exists, the opposite pattern shows up. The leaders who manage to bring their teams through a crisis are the ones willing to admit they don't have all the answers, and who invite anyone who can contribute knowledge to do so, regardless of what organization, profession, or rung of the hierarchy that knowledge comes from. John Chambers, who served for many years as CEO and Chairman of Cisco, described this shift plainly in a 2009 interview with the New York Times: "I am a man of command and control. I like to be able to say 'turn right,' and find that 67,000 men turn right. But this style is old-fashioned. The world today needs a different leadership style. More cooperation and teamwork."

Two Muscle Systems

Omri Gefen uses the image of two parallel muscle systems to describe what every senior leader needs: the first is the familiar, authoritative, centralized system, decisive and clear in direction; the second is collaborative, dialogical, and process-oriented. These two systems work in parallel, and neither should come at the expense of the other. A body that is very strong but inflexible is prone to injury; a body that is flexible but weak can't hold up either. The healthiest state combines both strength and flexibility. A leader who deeply understands collaboration is also, necessarily, one who deeply understands authority and control. A physical metaphor for this: a manager who replaces the long meeting table, where he once sat at the head, with a round one. It's a way of being. Not merely a symbolic act.

What It Looks Like in an Actual Crisis

The COVID-19 crisis that broke out in the spring of 2020 offered a particularly sharp field of comparison between leadership styles. Researchers pointed out that countries led by women, among them New Zealand, Taiwan, Iceland, and Germany, managed the crisis faster and with greater transparency than many countries led by men. The explanation wasn't gender itself, but a combination of traits that repeated across those leaders: immediate acknowledgment of the situation's severity instead of denial, telling the truth even when it wasn't comfortable, empathy toward the public, and alongside all of that, brave and fast decision-making when it was needed. These are exactly the two muscle systems described above, working together rather than one replacing the other.

Where to Actually Start

It starts with awareness. Developing an understanding of, and awareness toward, my own leadership style and perception of leadership, along with an honest and genuine inquiry into how relevant it still is to a changing reality. Is what was relevant in the past still relevant today and going forward? Does what worked well for me at lower levels of management still fit the level of complexity I face in a senior role? Does the world that has changed, with its complex and at times disrupted characteristics, and its high levels of chaos and uncertainty, allow me to operate with only one muscle system, or does it require moving with both? And can fulfilling my role and maximizing my impact be possible without a deep network of connections and collaborations?

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the difference between collaborative leadership and ordinary empowering leadership?

Empowering leadership mostly focuses on developing the people who report directly to the leader. Collaborative leadership widens the lens to the interfaces beyond the immediate team, between units, organizations, and even different sectors.

Can a naturally competitive, charismatic leader still be collaborative?

Yes. Many competitive leaders successfully combine both, as long as they consciously choose when to lead with authority and when to make room for listening. The problem starts when only one of the two ever gets used.

How can you tell if a leader is genuinely collaborative or just talks about it?

The difference shows up in actual meetings and decision processes: do differing opinions actually change the direction that gets chosen, or are they merely heard without affecting the outcome?

Can collaborative leadership be learned, or is it a personality trait?

It can be learned. It mostly comes down to self-awareness and ongoing practice in listening and making room for others, not a trait you either are or aren't born with.

About the Author

Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).

If you'd like to explore the level of collaboration in your own leadership team, you're welcome to schedule an introductory conversation through the consulting page on the site.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *