Collaboration & Trust |
Transforming Leadership

Organizational mediation is a structured dialogue process in which a neutral professional helps parties within an organization or between organizations understand each other's needs and interests and reach a solution everyone agrees to. It does not impose a decision, and its outcomes depend on the full consent of all parties. In organizational collaboration it serves both as a tool for preventing disputes and as a shared language for managing conflict before it explodes.

This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen. One of the insights running through the book concerns our relationship to conflict itself: "the new paradigm in collaboration regards conflict as an opportunity for mutual learning and relationship improvement."

What is organizational mediation?

Organizational mediation is much more than a dispute resolution technique. In Omri Gefen's approach, tools from mediation and consensus building are integrated into the collaborative work processes he calls ECP (Effective Collaboration Process). There they are applied in their advisory sense rather than their legal sense, and their purpose is to create a deep mutual understanding of needs, trust, relationships and effective communication. When mediation is embedded as a language, it stops being an emergency event and becomes a way of working.

This distinction matters. Most people encounter mediation only when something has already broken: partners who are fighting, units blaming each other, a supplier and a client at a dead end. In those situations mediation is a necessary response. Yet Omri Gefen proposes looking at organizational mediation as part of the architecture of the collaboration itself, something defined in advance and not called in only after the fact.

Omri Gefen has been working in mediation since the mid-1990s, when the field was almost unknown in Israel, and that is one reason he treats it as infrastructure rather than a trend. In his work with senior management teams, in complex processes within and between organizations and at the interfaces between sectors, he encounters the same phenomenon again and again: the conflict itself is almost never the core problem. The problem is the way it is managed, or the choice not to manage it at all.

Why don't courts resolve organizational conflicts?

In the book, Omri Gefen describes the phenomenon of "legalization", which has grown stronger over the years and intensifies both the fear barrier and the competitiveness barrier. Legal language is competitive and forceful by nature. Lawyers are trained to defend and to win, and contracts are written in the negative: what no one is responsible for, what happens if, which court will hear the case. This has its place in building partnerships. But not at the center.

The story that illustrates this most sharply comes from the head of the construction division of a large high-tech company. At a certain moment, in his words, the penny dropped: "All the construction projects we performed over the years ended up in court. Some of them involved very long trials. Whether we won or lost in court, we always lost."

His conclusion was a brave one. He decided that the legal adviser would go back to being an adviser rather than a leader, and that the next project would be run by an integrated team of the company and the contractor. The teams came together as one team, partly on the basis of an in-depth conversation about fears. A structured model of non-judicial mediation was built into the work process, alongside personal guidance for managers who were identified as more challenging in terms of collaboration. About a year after the project ended successfully and without any conflict requiring legal proceedings, he said he hoped the same contractor would win the next tender as well.

This is the real return on organizational mediation. A relationship that continues. The dispute that was resolved is only part of the story.

When is it right to turn to organizational mediation?

Omri Gefen's first answer is: before you need it. In the book he recommends embedding a conflict management mechanism as part of the communication structure of every collaboration, and agreeing on it in advance, while relations are still good. In collaboration within an organization, it is possible to rely on people inside the system. In collaboration between different entities, it is worth defining an external professional mechanism.

When a legal document defines the framework of the partnership, it includes a "stipulation of mediation" clause that obligates the parties to turn to mediation if a significant conflict arises. This means a clear commitment to try the channel of dialogue before any other procedure. Omri Gefen emphasizes what distinguishes mediation from any coercive procedure: "Naturally, the mediation outcomes are subject to the full consent of all the parties involved; thus, forcing a solution is not an option."

The arena where this need stands out most is partnerships between founders. In the book, Omri Gefen cites the research of Prof. Noam Wasserman of Harvard Business School, who studied about 10,000 founders from 4,000 startups and found that about two-thirds of the reasons for failure relate to the human element. In mediation processes with entrepreneurs and managers from this arena, he describes countless disputes arising from breaches of trust, communication difficulties and unclear definitions of roles and areas of responsibility.

The common denominator in many of these cases is what Omri Gefen calls the "it'll be okay" barrier. Partners arrive with initial trust that comes from acquaintance, not with the deep trust that enables joint work. They prefer to leave gray areas and let the elephants wander around the room. Later, disputes break out that could have been resolved in advance. We expanded on the difference between initial trust and well-established trust in the article on building trust in organizations.

Why does organizational mediation work?

Organizational mediation works because it brings needs and interests back to the center of the conversation. Most of us naturally communicate at the level of positions: demands, claims, proposals and solutions. At that level it is hard to truly understand what the other side needs, and even harder to build trust. A structured process allows all partners to go down to the level of needs, and there even conflicting needs sometimes become accessible and even solvable.

It also works because it does not try to eliminate conflict. Omri Gefen describes Gottman's research, which followed more than 2,000 couples over more than twenty years and found that disagreements and arguments are inevitable in every relationship. What determines stability is the way the parties discuss and resolve their conflicts. Organizations work the same way. A conflict management mechanism is not meant to create a dispute-free zone, but to prevent some disputes and manage the others.

And it works because someone in it is not afraid. Omri Gefen writes that most managers choose to avoid conflict, so a structured process needs a leader who is able to step into it. Sometimes the conflict itself is the opportunity to deepen mutual understanding. People value honesty and directness more than polite diplomacy.

Organizational mediation also works because of its structure. Omri Gefen explains that complexity is the natural starting point of many collaborations, which is why a structured and supported process matters: it creates a safe environment that allows openness alongside progress. The structure maintains focus and confidence along the way, and professional facilitation helps release barriers and ensures that communication difficulties and conflicts do not bring the process to a halt.

There is a close connection between organizational mediation and consensus building. Mediation usually deals with parties already in dispute, while consensus building is aimed at broad processes with many partners, sometimes before the conflict is visible. We wrote about the other side of the coin in the article on consensus building in complex organizations.

How to start in practice

Before turning to mediation, and even more so before getting caught in a dispute, it is worth pausing to ask a few honest questions.

Which conflict in my organization am I managing through lawyers, formal emails or silence, when I should really be managing it through conversation?

In the partnerships and collaborations I lead, have we defined in advance what we will do when there is a dispute? Or am I counting on it being okay?

When I enter a dispute, am I talking about my positions, or about the needs behind them? Do I know what the other side needs?

What do I lose even when I win? Which relationship erodes every time I insist on being right?

Do I have the courage to step into the conflict, or am I waiting for it to fade by itself?

And perhaps the most important question of all: do I see conflict as a threat to eliminate, or as an opportunity to learn something about my partners and about myself?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between organizational mediation and legal proceedings?

Legal proceedings decide who is right, while mediation looks for a solution all parties agree to. In mediation a solution cannot be forced, and the goal is to preserve the relationship rather than settle for ending the dispute.

When should an organization turn to mediation?

As early as possible, ideally before there is a conflict at all. Omri Gefen recommends defining a conflict management mechanism in advance in every partnership, and including a mediation clause in legal agreements.

Is mediation also suitable for collaboration within the organization?

Yes. In collaboration within an organization it is possible to rely on people inside the system, and in collaboration between organizations it is worth defining an external professional mechanism.

Why does mediation succeed where a court fails?

Because it deals with the needs and interests behind the positions, and allows the parties to keep working together. Even someone who wins in court may lose the partnership.

About the Author

Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).

If you are dealing with a complex conflict within your organization or between organizations, you are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's approach on the consulting page of the website.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *