Management development is an ongoing process of learning and training whose goal is to turn a group of managers into a team that leads the whole organization together, beyond each person's own unit. In Omri Gefen's approach, collaborative management development teaches managers to hold two axes at the same time: managing their unit in depth, and managing the interfaces with other units, management teams and organizations across the breadth. It requires an educational process, not a one-time workshop.
This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen, in which he sets out a principle that guides every management development process: "Cultivating a culture of collaboration rather than one of competitiveness is a change that requires an educational process."
What is collaborative management development?
Omri Gefen opens the discussion with a story about a coachman driving a wagon pulled by four young, strong horses that got stuck in deep mud. They tried forward and backward and could not get out. Then an older coachman passed by with a wagon pulled by three less impressive horses, crossed the mud easily and even pulled them out. Asked what the secret was, the older coachman said that the young one had gathered the strongest horses from different places, each full of self-importance and each raised alone. Whereas "My three horses spent their entire lives together and learned to work together from scratch. They learned from their very first days to cooperate".
This is exactly the challenge of most management teams. Organizations recruit and promote the strongest managers they can find. Each is excellent in their field. But they did not grow up together, and they did not learn to work together. Collaborative management development is the process that teaches them what the older coachman's horses learned from the first day.
According to Omri Gefen, training managers for collaboration should include both perceptions and practices, at every level of management. For junior managers the emphasis is teamwork. For all other levels the emphasis shifts to integrating and leading the interfaces between teams, and to planning and carrying out horizontal collaboration, inside the organization and outside it.
What is the difference between team development and management development?
Team development usually focuses on relationships and work within the team. Management development in Omri Gefen's approach also focuses on what happens between teams. He offers the model of T-Shaped Management. The vertical bar of the letter T represents managing the unit. The horizontal bar represents the ability to see and successfully manage the interfaces and collaborations with other units and organizations. A manager with only a vertical bar is a good unit manager. Not necessarily a member of a management team.
This distinction matters especially in organizations built as a matrix, where many managers report to two managers and are required to manage interfaces all the time. Omri Gefen notes that successfully implementing such a structure requires a collaborative culture and a high ability among managers to hold dialogue and build agreements. There, the horizontal bar is part of the job itself.
A practical recommendation follows from this. Omri Gefen notes that training that brings together role holders from different units that share interfaces is more effective in improving collaboration than training in which each unit learns alone. When a marketing department asks for training to improve its interface with the development department, it is worth bringing the development people into the training too. This creates a shared language and makes it possible to examine together the issues that concern both sides.
In his work with senior management teams and in complex processes within and between organizations, Omri Gefen sees again and again that the difficulty of a management team is not a lack of professionalism. Each of its members knows their job. The difficulty lies in breadth. In the ability to hold shared responsibility for the whole organization, beyond one's personal territory.
How does management development move from one team to collaboration between management teams?
One of the tools Omri Gefen recommends is the Offsite: a planned break from the work routine, for half a day or three days, in the desert or by the sea, in a setting that allows a conversation about relationships and collaboration. He compares it to a car that keeps driving under heavy load. Every so often it has to go into the garage, have the hood lifted and the oil changed. If it stays in the garage too long, it will not reach its destinations. If it never goes in, it will get stuck on the road.
Managers who finished a complex strategic process after two long days in the desert summed it up this way: "The result we have jointly achieved in recent days could not have been achieved elsewhere." The quiet, the lack of phone reception, the simplicity and the intimacy were part of the solution. Most management teams that experience this once incorporate this structure at least once a year, for years.
Management development does not have to start at the top. Emi Palmor, former Director General of Israel's Ministry of Justice, developed a program called the "Influencers Forum" for employees with up to six years of seniority, in a ministry with 5,000 employees, 40 units and divisions and about 70 sites across the country. She describes the starting point: "Due to its size and traditional perceptions, at the time the Ministry worked as a collection of silos." Alongside her work with senior management on shared interests between unit managers, she connected the young participants with each other, and at the end of the program asked them to present problems and solutions to management in mixed groups from different units. She made a point of choosing people who had not yet become fixed in the patterns of their unit, who could look at the organization with a critical eye and remain open to other ways of thinking.
The result was a network of about 90 graduates who knew each other and the different units. The graduates became sought-after candidates for senior assistant roles, and thus agents of change. Palmor personally led four rounds of the program. This is management development that works from the roots: training the next management to think across the organization before it becomes management.
Another arena for management development is integrated task teams. Omri Gefen describes teams that connect several units in an organization, or several organizations, around a project, an improvement team or a special mission. They identify the challenge together, agree on goals and process, hold discussions in which hierarchy is set aside, and build a work plan together. From a management development perspective these are living laboratories: managers learn to work across boundaries while doing real work, with people they will need to work with tomorrow as well.
Why does management development fail when it stays in the classroom?
Management development fails when it is treated as an event rather than a process. Omri Gefen emphasizes that the shift from competitiveness to collaboration is a cultural change, and therefore requires an ongoing educational process. An impressive workshop after which everyone returns to their silo changes nothing. What changes things is combining learning with permanent work structures: joint retreats, mixed forums, training in which those who work together sit together.
Omri Gefen adds that what the organization rewards sends a stronger message than any training. If managers are measured and rewarded only for performance in their own territory, the development process will collide with reality first thing on Monday morning. We expanded on the link between management development and deep change in organizational culture in the article on organizational transformation.
There is also a personal price. Managers who advanced thanks to their ability to lead a unit alone are suddenly required to share, to expose themselves, to ask for help. This does not come naturally to many of them. That is why good training deals with tools and with ego alike.
How to start in practice
Before building a management development program, it is worth pausing to ask a few honest questions.
Is my management team a team that grew up together, or a collection of strong horses, each of which grew up alone?
How much of my time do I invest in the vertical bar of the T, and how much in the horizontal bar?
When I send my people to training, are the people they work with in their interfaces sitting in the room with them?
When did my management team last step out of the routine to talk about the way we work together, rather than about the tasks?
Whom in the organization am I training today to think across units, before they reach a management role?
And perhaps the most important question of all: does what I reward in the organization reinforce what I am trying to teach?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the goal of collaborative management development?
To turn a group of strong managers into a team that leads the organization together. The goal is for each manager to manage both their own unit and its interfaces with other units and organizations well.
What is T-Shaped Management?
A dual management concept that Omri Gefen incorporates into training. The vertical bar represents managing the unit, and the horizontal bar represents the ability to manage interfaces and horizontal collaboration.
Why is it worth training managers from different units together?
Because joint training creates a shared language and makes it possible to examine the interface issues together. According to Omri Gefen, it is more effective in improving collaboration than separate training for each unit.
Is a management Offsite just team bonding?
No. It is a communication structure that allows a management team to pause the routine and talk about their relationships and collaboration. Most management teams that experience it incorporate it at least once a year.
About the Author
Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).
If your management team wants to build real collaboration within it and with other management teams, you are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's approach on the consulting page of the website.