Elements of collaboration are the four foundations on which every collaboration rests, according to Omri Gefen's Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model: value, structure, relationships and commitment. They answer three questions: why we are in the interface, how it is supposed to work, and what we actually do. Each element is worth a quarter of the whole, and a weak element weakens all of them.
This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen, in which he calls the four elements the "basic food groups" of every collaboration and reminds us that they serve one purpose: "Partnership, at any level, is a means of serving the creation of value."
What are the four elements of collaboration?
Omri Gefen connects the elements to Simon Sinek's "Golden Circle". Value answers the question "Why?". Structure and relationships answer the question "How?", at the formal and informal levels. And commitment answers the question "What?", what we actually do. Sinek wrote: "Very few people or companies can clearly articulate WHY they do what they do." Omri Gefen argues that this is true of partnerships as well.
He chose a pyramid to illustrate the interdependence between the elements. If stones fall from one face, the other faces weaken too, and at some point stones begin to fall from them as well. No element can hold on its own over time. A collaboration that rests only on good relationships, or only on orderly procedures, will be shaken at the first moment of pressure.
Why is value the first element?
Value is the potential gain of each partner, whether a person, a unit or an organization. Not behavioral values, but goals, needs, interests, motives and constraints. In this element we examine the potential, the goals of each party and the shared goals, and the proximity to the core of each organization's vision. The closer the issue is to the core, the more meaningful the interface. If the issue is marginal for one side, it will show in implementation.
The most important part of value is the interests of the organizations and the personal needs of their leaders. Omri Gefen argues that there is no chance a person will truly cooperate if it does not meet some need for them personally or for the organization they represent. And this is also the big challenge: we often make assumptions about the other side's motives without checking, and sometimes we are not even aware of the order of priority of our own needs.
What is the difference between structure and relationships?
Structure deals with the formal aspects: organizational structure, shared information systems, communication structures, responsibility and authority, work processes and procedures. Without structure, ambiguity is too high and dependence on personal relationships becomes excessive. Yet too many definitions also cause harm, because they erase agility.
Relationships deal with the informal and interpersonal aspects: the sense of partnership, trust, the quality of dialogue, conflict management, tolerance and inclusion, and understanding the other side's organizational culture. Omri Gefen emphasizes trust as the most important lever in this element, and adds that "trust is not decided by a higher power or by the other’s actions but can be managed in a deliberate and intelligent manner." We expanded on building trust itself in this series in the article on building trust in organizations.
Why is commitment a separate element?
Commitment and implementation are the translation into action: transparency, priorities, availability, resources, execution and dealing with conflicts of interest. Omri Gefen included them in the model as an element of equal weight in order to assert the importance of implementation, because "The most dangerous thing is the disparity between statements and actions." Partners declare the importance of collaboration, and in practice do not cash the checks they signed.
The elements work together with the levels of collaboration. In coordination, the emphasis in value is on information, and in commitment on transparency. In cooperation, the emphasis shifts to shared results, definitions of responsibility and carrying out tasks. In deep collaboration, deeply understood interests, shared platforms, high trust and shared goals are required. We expanded on the levels themselves in the article on the three levels of collaboration.
In his work with senior management teams and in complex processes within and between organizations, Omri Gefen uses the four elements as a map. When an interface creaks, the map makes it possible to ask where exactly, instead of blaming the other side.
How to start in practice
It is worth choosing one interface that matters to me, and asking four questions about it.
Value: do I know what my partner gains from this interface? And what do I gain?
Structure: is it clear who is responsible for what, how decisions are made and how we communicate?
Relationships: how much do I trust them, and how much do they trust me? What have I done recently to strengthen that?
Commitment: do my actions match what I have declared?
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the four elements of collaboration?
Value, structure, relationships and commitment. These are the four faces of the pyramid in Omri Gefen's ECA model, and each of them is worth a quarter of the whole.
Which element is the most important?
They all depend on each other, and a weak element weakens the others. Value is the starting point, because without clear value there is no real reason to cooperate.
What does a gap between high value and low commitment mean?
It is a gap between declarations and actions. Everyone agrees the interface is important, but in practice no one invests in it, and this usually leads to a decline in trust.
About the Author
Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).
If you want to understand which element is missing in your organization's interfaces, you are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's way of working on the consulting page of the website.