Collaboration & Trust |
Transforming Leadership

Consensus building is a structured process in which everyone involved thinks together about a shared challenge, understands in depth the needs and interests of each party, and reaches decisions they can stand behind and act on. It does not require everyone to agree on everything, and it gives no one a veto. In complex organizations it works when there is a clear outline, someone who holds the process, and a willingness to step into conflict instead of walking around it.

This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen, in which he takes apart one of the most common assumptions about agreement: "Creating value in processes, in relationships as a whole and particularly in partnerships, does not require absolute consent on every issue."

What is consensus building, and what is it not?

When managers hear the word consensus, many of them picture a meeting room nobody leaves until everyone nods. That is exactly the image that paralyzes processes. Omri Gefen reminds us that the original meaning of the term is to feel or think together. The goal is dialogue, understanding and a real opportunity to influence. Not full agreement, and not a veto for every participant.

In the book, consensus building is one of the pillars of the collaborative work processes Omri Gefen calls ECP, alongside tools that come from the world of mediation. These tools are not brought in their legal sense but as a shared language, one meant to create mutual understanding of needs, trust and effective communication. Before entering the process, a diagnosis based on the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model helps clarify who needs to be in the room and what the conversation is really about. Consensus building is also the root of the Collective Impact model, developed in the United States in 2011 as its evolution, which we explored in the article on Collective Impact in Israel.

The assumption underlying consensus building is simple and challenging at the same time. The people involved in the process know what works for them and what does not, and they are capable of producing the most practical solutions. What they usually lack is an organizing framework, professional guidance and an orderly process. In practice, this means designing a process that invites maximum participation and involvement while preserving the ability to decide and move forward.

In his work with senior management teams and in complex processes within and between organizations, Omri Gefen sees a recurring pattern: most managers choose to avoid conflict, which is why a consensus building process needs a leader who is not afraid of it. At the same time, field experience shows that people value honesty and directness more than polite diplomacy, and at the end of such processes managers often say that the encounter itself, the shared state of being and the listening, was among the most significant gains for them.

Why does consensus building get stuck in complex organizations?

The larger and more fragmented the system, the more agreements erode between the silos. The public sector may be the sharpest example, and Omri Gefen devotes an entire chapter to it, drawing on close familiarity with the field. Many managers avoid conflict with peers in the spaces between units, so issues remain vague or get closed with a mediocre compromise. No one integrates the whole, each unit has its own targets, and the price of escalating a dispute for a decision is high.

Udi Prawer, former Deputy General Director for governance and social affairs in the Prime Minister's Office, describes in the book the paradox at the heart of this work: "If you know what you want in great detail, you may paradoxically find yourself as far away from building consensus as possible." Whoever comes to the table with a closed solution is really coming for approval. Whoever is willing to set out with everyone on a journey of discovery and trust building is in a completely different place.

Prof. Eugene Kandel, who headed Israel's National Economic Council, describes what makes it possible to build agreement when you have no authority: "How was cooperation eventually made possible? Only when you prove to people that you are truly cooperative, that you are not going to take their credit, nor penetrate their territory". Trust is the precondition. Not the outcome.

There are also examples of systems that chose consensus building as a permanent way of working. In the Netherlands, a body made up of workers, employers and public representatives in equal share operates with the state serving only as an observer (SEP). There, agreements are formed on labor legislation and regulations and passed to the government and parliament as a joint advisory body. More than 90% of its recommendations are adopted.

How do you sustain a consensus building process over time?

A consensus building process does not end with one good meeting. In the Prime Minister's Office they developed a methodology in which they convened the widest possible team for a discussion called "a decision to launch a process". There they realized that a full year was needed, with key events to accelerate collaboration, public participation and data collection. The process usually started with objections. That is not a malfunction. It is the natural starting point.

Omri Gefen emphasizes that reciprocity is a basic condition. Whoever is asked to share in the fruits must feel that they also share in the risks, rather than carrying them alone: "People do not tend to cooperate or enter into partnerships when they believe that the risk they are taking is greater than that taken by the other party." When one side feels it is paying more, the agreement cracks before it is even signed.

Another principle Omri Gefen proposes is the 80-20 rule. In long processes it is worth identifying the low-hanging fruit early, the 20 percent of investment that produces 80 percent of the impact, and creating quick wins. Early successes recruit the opponents and those sitting on the fence, and strengthen those who are already doing the work. Success begets success.

And at the heart of it all are the people. The direct, structured encounter, where it is possible to talk, listen and better understand others, is what creates the experience of connection. Not everything is pleasant in such encounters. And that is not the goal.

How to start in practice

Before starting a consensus building process, it is worth pausing to ask a few honest questions.

Am I entering this conversation with a ready-made solution, or with a real question? Am I willing to discover that my answer is not the answer?

Do I know the needs and interests behind the other side's positions? And what lies behind my own positions?

Am I looking for everyone to agree with me, or for everyone to feel that they were heard and had real influence?

Is the risk I am asking my partners to take equal to the risk I am taking myself?

Which dispute have I been postponing for months because it is uncomfortable, and how much will it cost us if it blows up at a later stage?

Who is not in the room, yet will be directly affected by the decision?

And the last question, perhaps the most important of all: does what worked for me in the past, deciding alone and moving fast, fit the complexity of the system I operate in today?

Frequently Asked Questions

Does consensus building mean everyone has to agree on everything?

No. The goal is dialogue, understanding and the opportunity to influence. No participant holds a veto, and full agreement on every issue is not necessarily reached.

What is the difference between consensus building and mediation?

Mediation usually deals with a conflict that has already erupted between parties. Consensus building is aimed at processes with many partners, sometimes before the conflict is even visible. In the book, both sets of tools are integrated into ECP processes as a shared language rather than a legal instrument.

How long does a consensus building process take?

It depends on scope and complexity. In the Prime Minister's Office they realized that a systemic process requires a year, with key events, public participation and data collection along the way.

Who should lead the process?

Someone who can serve as a center of gravity and is not afraid of conflict. When the leaders are also parties to the matter, a neutral professional can help hold the outline.

About the Author

Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).

If you are facing a consensus building process in your organization, you are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's approach on the consulting page of the website.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *