Collaboration & Trust |
Transforming Leadership

The ECA model is the Effective Collaboration Architecture model developed by Omri Gefen, and it serves as a conceptual framework, a shared language and a diagnostic tool for collaboration within and between organizations. It is built as a pyramid with three levels of collaboration and four elements: value, structure, relationships and commitment. Using a short questionnaire, it turns what is perceived as "soft" and vague into a clear, quantitative picture of the interface.

This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen. In the book he describes what the diagnosis makes possible: "The model reflects the quality of partnerships using quantitative data, by means of a purely subjective view of those involved, and based on the model’s four elements."

Why was the ECA model developed?

The ECA model was born out of the need to define, measure and manage collaboration in a structured and systematic way. Omri Gefen notes that every other management field, from project management to budget planning, has an orderly discipline and methodology. Collaboration did not. When he found no systematic model for designing and managing collaboration, he built one himself, based on extensive experience in processes within and between organizations, across all sectors.

Another driver was the need to measure. For years many managers saw collaboration as something pleasant and secondary, part of the "soft" worlds. The ability to translate this space into precise numbers creates clarity, and moves the discussion from feelings to decisions.

The model is built as a pyramid, and this is not an aesthetic choice. A pyramid has layers, each of which is the foundation for the one above it. Its faces depend on each other, and a weak face weakens all of them. It symbolizes stability in a world of change. And it is easy to remember. The strength of the model, according to Omri Gefen, lies in its simplicity.

How does a diagnosis based on the ECA model work?

The diagnosis is based on a short questionnaire completed by those involved in the interface. Each side rates the four elements, and the result is a comparative picture of how each side perceives the interface. As a rule, any result below a rating of 5 indicates a gap that needs attention, and a rating of 4 or below indicates a serious situation. It is worth carrying out the diagnosis before deciding on the structure of an intervention process, and also afterwards, to see what has changed.

One example from the book concerns two companies, one from England and one from the United States, that had to work in close collaboration while the interface between them was full of conflicts. Each side blamed the other. The diagnosis pinpointed the gap: the English managers rated very low their understanding of the needs and interests of their American colleagues, and even lower the Americans' understanding of their own needs. This is a failure in the value element. Based on the diagnosis, 30 managers from both organizations built together a clear foundation of interests and needs that had been missing for years. Solving the gap in the value element also improved the other elements and mutual trust.

The ECA model is also used beyond the interface between two units. In the interface between court presidents and chief clerks, the diagnosis helped name the problem: where the authority of the middle level ends and the authority of the senior level begins. In the security system, 220 middle managers from three organizations answered the questionnaire, and the most prominent result pointed to a failure in the relationships between the heads of the organizations themselves. Placing the results on their table was a significant catalyst for taking responsibility.

What do the relationships between the four elements reveal?

The fascinating part of the diagnosis, according to Omri Gefen, lies in the balances between the elements. High structure and low relationships reflect collaboration held together by procedures, bureaucracy and hierarchy. High relationships and low structure reflect trust and flow, alongside ambiguity and disorder. And when value is high but commitment is low, this is a gap between declarations and actions, and low trust in management's intentions should be expected.

An especially common pattern is that each side is sure it invests more than the other. Omri Gefen describes a process at a global internet company in which the manager of a European unit did not understand why her colleagues rated her unit's commitment low. He asked her how many people were in the unit, how many of them worked in the interface with headquarters, and how much of their time was devoted to it. Her last answer was: "Maybe one percent of their activity per month is devoted to the other interfaces". The moment she said it, she understood. It was a turning point in the process.

Sometimes the diagnosis surprises in the opposite direction. At FIFCO in Costa Rica, which employs 6,000 people, commitment was rated higher than all the other elements. The explanation came from the local culture, Pura Vida: simplicity, goodwill, care for others and positive energy. That is what created high commitment in the interfaces, even though the other three elements were rated lower. The ECA model does not explain the culture. But it makes it visible.

In his work with senior management teams and in complex processes within and between organizations, Omri Gefen uses the ECA model precisely for moments like these. The data is placed in front of decision makers and is hard to deny. It is not a general or psychological description, but a call to action. And even before any result, the encounter with the questionnaire itself calibrates awareness and gets managers thinking about collaboration systematically.

With all that, Omri Gefen warns that "it should be borne in mind that the model is merely a tool and should not be glorified at all costs." What really matters are the outcomes and effects of the processes the diagnosis sets in motion. We expanded on how diagnosis fits into a broader consulting process in the article on organizational consulting.

How to start in practice

Before diagnosing an interface, it is worth pausing to ask.

Which interface in my organization has been running for a long time on feelings, accusations and stories, without data?

If I rated this interface on the four elements, which would be the lowest? And what would I discover if my partner rated it?

How much of my people's time is actually devoted to the interfaces I declare are important?

Am I willing to see data showing that the gap is also on my side?

And what will I do with the results: use them to prove I am right, or to open a conversation?

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the ECA model?

The Effective Collaboration Architecture model developed by Omri Gefen. It is built as a pyramid with three levels of collaboration, Coordination, Cooperation and Collaboration, and four elements: value, structure, relationships and commitment.

How is an ECA diagnosis carried out?

Through a short questionnaire completed by those involved in the interface. The results show each side's perception of each element, making it possible to identify gaps and strengths.

When should an ECA diagnosis be carried out?

Before deciding on an intervention process, and also afterwards to measure change. It is possible to diagnose a specific interface between two units or organizations, or the level of collaboration across the whole organization.

What does a low result in the commitment element mean?

It is usually the result of weakness in other elements, or of a gap between declarations and actions. A common pattern is that each side is sure it invests more than the other.

About the Author

Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).

Organizations that want an accurate picture of collaboration in their interfaces are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's way of working on the consulting page of the website.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *