Cross-compensation is a mechanism in which part of managers' rewards is determined by the success of parallel units or of the organization as a whole, in addition to the achievement of their own unit. Omri Gefen describes it as a deep perceptual shift without which it is hard to implement other collaborative solutions. When my bonus depends only on my own territory, I have no real reason to help others.
This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen, in which he describes an argument between a VP and his managers about compensation, and sums it up in a few words: "He was right, but so were they."
Why is cross-compensation needed?
A VP at a technology company led a process of organizational change and of embedding collaboration in his division and with the other divisions. His directive was clear and agreed. But as the process advanced, the managers said that as long as their reward mechanism stayed as it was, there was no chance of change. Each department operated as an independent profit and loss unit, and the managers received significant bonuses for their own achievements only.
The managers said honestly that because of the reward model, they preferred to pay an external supplier, even a competitor, for a cheaper service, although it was clear to them that it was better to get the service from a parallel department and thus strengthen the organization. The VP insisted that work processes could change without changing compensation, believing that his managers were driven by values and organizational responsibility. The argument went on for almost a year, without significant change.
In the end the VP understood, and created cross-unit compensation in addition to departmental compensation. "It did not take long before a dramatic positive change took place in division collaborations."
What does a cross-compensation model look like?
Omri Gefen gives an example from a business group in the construction field, where they understood that without cross-compensation it would be hard to implement the other solutions for collaboration. A uniform, cross-company mechanism was built and applied only at the three senior levels. The CEOs' bonus was defined as 70 percent based on their company's output and 30 percent on the group's output. At the second and third levels, a key of 80 percent company, 10 percent group and 10 percent personal goals was defined.
For years the CEOs had received a bonus based on 100 percent of their own output, with full control over their territory, so the change was dramatic and affected all work processes in the group. Omri Gefen warns against the perception that this is simple: "This kind of outcome, which seems virtually simple, is based on a process laden with conflicts and challenges."
There is also another version, applied in some organizations: a manager's personal bonus is granted only if their parallel managers also met their goals and were rewarded as well.
Why are values alone not enough?
The VP's story illustrates a real tension. He was right to believe that managers can act out of values and organizational responsibility. And they were right to say that a reward system that rewards only separate achievement sends the opposite message. In his work with senior management teams and in complex processes within and between organizations, Omri Gefen meets this gap again and again: management declares collaboration, and the reward system tells a different story. And people believe the reward system.
Cross-compensation complements shared objectives. When both objectives and rewards reflect joint success, the message is clear. We expanded on the objectives side in the article on shared objectives between units.
How to start in practice
It is worth putting the compensation model on the table and asking.
What exactly are my managers rewarded for today, and what does that teach them about collaboration?
Is there a manager of mine for whom it pays to buy a service from outside instead of from a parallel unit?
What percentage of the bonus, even a small one, could reflect the success of the organization or of parallel units?
And me: am I willing for my own reward to depend on the success of others too?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is cross-compensation?
A mechanism in which part of managers' rewards is determined by the success of parallel units or of the whole organization, in addition to their own unit's achievement.
What does a cross-compensation model look like in practice?
In the group Omri Gefen describes, the CEOs' bonus was based on 70 percent company output and 30 percent group output, and at the next levels on 80 percent company, 10 percent group and 10 percent personal goals.
Can collaboration be strengthened without changing compensation?
It is very hard. According to the experience Omri Gefen describes, when compensation stayed separate the change stalled, and when cross-unit compensation was added, collaboration improved quickly.
About the Author
Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).
Organizations that want to align their reward mechanisms with the collaboration they are trying to build are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's way of working on the consulting page of the website.