Holacracy is an organizational model that abolishes traditional hierarchy and replaces it with independent functional circles, in which there is no definition of managers and employees, and the rules are set in a charter that all employees take part in writing. Its core values are equality and collaboration. Omri Gefen sees it as an extreme expression of a broad trend, the declining power of hierarchy, and warns that it does not suit every organization or every employee.
This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen, in which he describes holacracy as part of the revolution sweeping through the world of organizations, and sums up its spirit in one sentence: "What makes this strategy a winner is the power of idea rather than the power of authority."
What is holacracy?
The name holacracy derives from the ancient Greek word holon, meaning a part of something big, whole and complete. In a holacratic organization the structure is completely flat. Employees belong to work groups according to their skills and wishes. Each circle is independently responsible for a certain area, and within it there is no hierarchical management. Circles can work in parallel or be subordinate to other circles, and a new circle can be born from an existing one when there is a task to perform.
Circles include representatives of other circles, creating a broad picture and synergistic work. Each role holder has a defined purpose, areas of responsibility and assets, and each employee or team determines their own course of action, as long as they do not harm the work of others. This is not anarchy. Everything is based on a clear framework of rules.
Why do organizations move to holacracy?
Omri Gefen explains that this method makes much more sense to the younger generation. Millennials, generations Y and Z, engage and contribute more in flat structures than in hierarchical ones. Sharing information is natural for them, and they do not like hierarchical management, certainly not rigid management.
Alongside this, the stock of hierarchy is in constant decline within organizations themselves. As information spreads to all levels rather than staying concentrated at the top of the pyramid, senior managers hold less knowledge and depend more on employees. In an era in which information is power, power in its previous form weakens. Holacracy is a structural answer to this reality: freedom of action, expression and thought that produce involvement, commitment and faster, better solutions, without the need for managers' approvals or organizational politics.
This trend is also familiar from high-tech organizations. Omri Gefen describes Scrum, a method for managing software development projects based on agility, transparency, continuous learning and self-directed teams. It assumes that in a complex world it is impossible to plan everything in advance. Holacracy takes the same logic one step further, from the level of the team to the level of the whole organization.
What are the drawbacks of holacracy?
Omri Gefen does not present holacracy as a magic solution. "The concept of self-management of employees is not suitable for everyone." He cites Zappos, the giant American online shoe and clothing company, which moved to holacracy in 2014 and is described as a success story. On the other hand, Twitter tried working this way and realized along the way that the method also has drawbacks.
The drawbacks are tangible. Evaluation, feedback and control are difficult to sustain in a holacratic organization, even though they are very important for a healthy work environment. And not all employees are capable of the same degree of self-management. For them, holacracy does not provide a safety net.
What can be adopted from holacracy without abolishing hierarchy?
Omri Gefen admits that "The idea of abolishing traditional management is still hard to digest." But the ideas at the base of holacracy, teams without formal management, an emphasis on teamwork and less bureaucracy, are gaining momentum in many organizations, in different forms. Experts estimate that more and more organizations will operate according to such a framework, or will be founded on it from the start.
In his work with senior management teams and in complex processes within and between organizations, Omri Gefen meets managers standing between two worlds: on one side, hierarchical structures that are falling apart, and on the other, technologies that increase control. The practical question is usually not whether to move to full holacracy, but where power can be shifted from authority to ideas. A project team with full responsibility, a forum without ranks, a decision made close to the field.
We expanded on the deep change in management thinking behind this trend in the article on organizational transformation.
How to start in practice
Before getting excited about holacracy, or rejecting it, it is worth asking.
In which decisions in my organization does the power of authority beat the power of ideas, and what are we losing because of it?
Which of my employees would thrive in self-management, and who would lack a safety net?
What would feedback, evaluation and control look like for us if we flattened the structure?
And where can we start small, in one team, before changing the whole organization?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is holacracy?
An organizational model without traditional hierarchy, in which work is carried out in independent functional circles according to areas of responsibility, and the rules are set in a charter shared by all employees.
Is holacracy suitable for every organization?
No. Omri Gefen notes that self-management is not suitable for everyone, and that evaluation, feedback and control are hard to maintain in a holacratic organization. Some organizations succeeded, like Zappos, and some discovered the drawbacks, like Twitter.
Can ideas from holacracy be adopted without abolishing hierarchy?
Yes. Teams without formal management, an emphasis on teamwork and reduced bureaucracy are ideas many organizations adopt gradually, within an existing structure.
About the Author
Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).
Organizations considering flattening their structure or strengthening work in independent teams are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's way of working on the consulting page of the website.