Negotiation management is the process in which parties with different interests try to reach an agreement, and in complex organizations it succeeds when it shifts from arguing over positions to a dialogue about needs and interests. In Omri Gefen's approach, effective negotiation starts with two simple questions: why is this important to you, and what is important to you. From there it is possible to create solutions that neither side would have reached alone.
This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen. In the book he describes the pattern most of us know from home and from work: "The classic and familiar negotiation most of us were raised on is a chronicle of a predetermined dance between two positions."
What is needs-based negotiation management?
Needs-based negotiation management is an approach in which the parties do not stay on the surface of their demands, but go down to the question of what lies behind them. Omri Gefen distinguishes between three layers: position, need and solution. The position is what I demand. I demand that an employee arrive at a certain time, that a colleague submit a report, that a supplier deliver a perfect product. The need is what really matters to me. And the solution is what is chosen in the end.
The problem, according to Omri Gefen, is a pattern he calls being "bottom-line oriented". We define a position, and from there we move quickly, automatically and directly to alternatives and solutions. We are solution-focused and impatient with the process required to reach the right solution. This is how negotiation becomes bargaining. Not a conversation with depth that also takes the ongoing relationship into account.
Why does negotiating over positions get stuck?
Negotiating over positions gets stuck because it moves along one axis only. Omri Gefen compares it to a cha-cha-cha dance, back and forth on the same line. If one side says 100 and the other says 200, the solution will land somewhere in between, through force or compromise. There is no synergistic view and no real chance of a solution in which everyone gains.
Legal proceedings work the same way. Statements of claim present positions, each position is backed by explanations and justifications, and the judge decides on the axis between them or forms a compromise within the same space. Our social discourse is heavily influenced by this approach, which is why it seems natural to behave this way. We bring the bargaining pattern home too, to our spouses and children. And in conflicts, positions become entrenched.
The price is high. When we harden our own position and attack the other's, the other side hardens too. Emotions overpower judgment, and we enter escalations and cycles of wasted energy. The attempt to create a discourse fades in the face of two monologues. The stronger side imposes its position, or a compromise is reached that no one is truly satisfied with.
How do you move from positions to needs in a negotiation?
The most precise tool, according to Omri Gefen, is the simplest one: asking questions. He calls two of them "the million-dollar questions". The first is "Why?", asked about the position in a clean, non-judgmental and non-defiant way, out of genuine curiosity. Sometimes it needs to be asked several times during the conversation. The second is "What is important to you?", which is aimed precisely at understanding the needs of the person in front of me.
The orange story illustrates this well. A father comes home and finds his two children fighting over the last orange. He cuts it in half and divides it. Then he sees that his son squeezes his half into a glass because he was thirsty, and that his daughter peels hers to make candied orange peel. Each received half of the potential, and half an orange went into the trash. Had he asked why the orange mattered to them, both would have received everything they needed.
Life is not an orange. But Omri Gefen argues that in many more situations than we tend to think, it is possible to find the orange element, the one that changes the way the situation is seen. In an organizational context, it is worth distinguishing between the needs of people and the interests of the organization. When a person represents a unit or an organization, there are always personal needs there too. Effective negotiation addresses both. When only one of them is addressed, the interface remains weak.
Most of the significant needs are actually the intangible ones. Omri Gefen distinguishes between tangible needs, such as resources, time, pay, information and formal authority, and intangible needs, such as belonging, influence, development, independence and recognition. An employee who asks for a raise is often also asking for recognition of their value. Intangible needs drive us more, and harming them is a major source of rifts and crises of trust. They are also harder to identify, because they are perceived as each person's soft belly. And sometimes they are precisely the easier ones to fulfill. Recognizing a partner's value is possible even when there are no resources.
Should I reveal my needs in a negotiation?
The traditional approach to negotiation says no. Omri Gefen describes it as the instinct to "keep your cards close to your chest to prevent the other from recognizing your soft belly." The fear is understandable: the other side might use the information manipulatively. Yet innovative approaches argue the opposite. Whoever hides their needs may get the position they presented, and not what they really needed.
This does not mean sharing everything from the first moment. Omri Gefen recommends expressing needs gradually and wisely, with the right timing and dosage. It is better to do so after I have listened to the other side's needs, because then they are more attentive to mine as well. It is worth phrasing a need positively: instead of "I am not willing", say "it is important to me". And expressing my own needs creates modeling, which is often the catalyst that encourages the other side to share as well.
Omri Gefen also warns against what he calls "the proximity trap": the expectation that those close to us will understand on their own what we need, without our saying it. In long partnerships and in interfaces with longtime colleagues this happens a lot. When needs go unspoken, the relationship becomes less precise, and the gaps between the parties become blurred.
Another important distinction is between understanding and agreement. If I listen to the other only through the question of whether I agree with them, I cannot really listen. When the two are separated, it becomes possible to understand the other side in depth without giving anything up. The tool of reflection helps here: making sure I understood correctly, and sometimes rephrasing a position as a need. We expanded on listening and on understanding needs as the basis of all collaboration in the article on collaborative intelligence.
In work with senior management teams and in leading complex processes within and between organizations, and in the negotiation training Omri Gefen heads in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, the same insight comes up again and again: the difficulty is not the technique but the habit. Over the years Omri Gefen developed a model of dialogue-based negotiation that is taught and implemented in many organizations. In the book he describes a security-business organization that decided to train all relevant role holders in a structured negotiation methodology. The divisions asked to train separately, and after a process of several months their heads were persuaded to train in mixed groups. At the end of the training, participants emphasized the value of one shared language for all negotiation teams.
How to start in practice
Before my next negotiation, inside the organization or outside it, it is worth pausing to ask.
What is my position, and what need lies behind it? Am I even able to articulate it?
What is the other side's need? Did I ask them why, and what is important to them, or did I assume I already know?
Am I listening in order to understand, or in order to answer? Am I confusing understanding with agreement?
What information about my needs am I hiding out of fear, and what might that cost me?
Am I looking for the whole orange, or rushing to cut it in half?
And perhaps the most important question of all: am I managing this negotiation as a one-time bargain, or as part of a relationship that will continue tomorrow?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a position and a need in negotiation?
A position is what I demand, and a need is the reason it matters to me. Positions are above the surface, while needs are usually beneath it and must be asked about to be discovered.
How do you identify the other side's needs?
With two questions: "Why?" and "What is important to you?". They should be asked sincerely and out of curiosity, not as a tactic. The tool of reflection helps make sure the understanding is accurate.
Doesn't revealing my needs weaken me in a negotiation?
Not necessarily. Whoever hides their needs may get the position they presented rather than what they really need. It is important to reveal needs gradually, at the right time and on the basis of trust.
Why is negotiation management in an organization different from bargaining?
Because in an organization the parties keep working together after the agreement. Negotiation within an organization has to address both the interests of the units and the needs of the people who represent them.
About the Author
Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).
If you are managing a complex negotiation within your organization or with external partners, you are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's approach on the consulting page of the website.