Coopetition, a combination of cooperation and competition, describes a situation in which organizations or units compete with each other while cooperating at the same time. Omri Gefen sees it as one of the most powerful levers for creating relevance in the new era, and sometimes as the only condition for survival in a world of volatility and uncertainty. The key to managing it is a clear separation between the arenas in which parties compete and the arenas in which they cooperate.
This article is based on the book "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" by Omri Gefen, in which he opens the chapter on the subject with the sentence: "The highly complex relationship between competitors, albeit with the most significant advantages, occurs when competitors also cooperate."
What is coopetition?
Coopetition is an oxymoronic term that blurs the sharp distinction between competition and collaboration, a distinction that characterized the old world. Omri Gefen recalls what many of us learned in basic military training: to distinguish between "our forces" and "the enemy". Friend or foe. It is a deep and ancient perception. But this dichotomous line is blurring, making room for a space without clear boundaries, which fits neither the win-lose mindset nor the classic win-win mindset.
In diplomacy people now speak of a "frenemy", a friend and an enemy at the same time. In the organizational arena there are many examples. Oracle and Microsoft compete and partner in the server and cloud arena. The Israeli company SCD is the product of a partnership between Rafael and Elbit. Airlines compete with each other and share alliances that create value for customers. And Harvard and MIT established EDX together, the first and largest online university in the world.
Why do competitors cooperate?
Competitors cooperate because alone they can no longer create the value required. The high-tech arena illustrates this well. The pace of change makes agility, innovation and collaboration existential conditions, and the old separation between software, hardware and infrastructure companies has disappeared. When Satya Nadella became CEO of Microsoft in 2014, he created a collaboration with Apple, and made it clear that Apple was and would remain a significant competitor. Value to customers is also value to companies.
Crises accelerate the trend. In April 2020 Google and Apple developed together a technology that alerted users to proximity to Covid patients. Medtronic publicly shared the specifications of its ventilator so that manufacturers around the world could produce similar machines. Omri Gefen notes that the move did not stem from values alone, and the company also gained favorable exposure and a rise in its shares. Still, allowing competitors to use knowledge reflects a new perception of competition.
Omri Gefen emphasizes that this is not about creating cartels. The boundary is clear, but sometimes thin, so it is important to stay within the legitimate playing field and the legal boundaries. In a process he describes between two competing educational networks in Israel, the two CEOs took a brave step and initiated an in-depth process with both management teams. It was agreed to compete respectfully, explore joint procurement and hold joint activities for staff and students. Pedagogical differentiation was actually strengthened, and the tenders on which the networks competed were left out of the conversation in advance.
How do you manage coopetition without the contradiction tearing it apart?
The central question, according to Omri Gefen, is how to manage a relationship that contains a contradiction at its core: possible hostility because of conflicting interests alongside possible friendship because of shared interests. People find it very hard to compete and cooperate with the same party at the same time. It requires high awareness, experience and the ability to manage a dual relationship.
The answer he offers is structural separation. In Sweden, two companies producing protective packaging materials compete fiercely for every customer, while cooperating in their development labs to save on research costs. The development manager described it this way: "We experience a good atmosphere of cooperation in the technical sphere. Competition and resentment exist only in the market arena." The sales manager, by contrast, said that when they win a customer from the other company they buy a cake and celebrate.
Hence the principle: "the closer you are to the customer, the more competition will exist between organizations." And the further you move from the customer, the easier it is to cooperate. Two Swedish breweries work the same way, competing in marketing and distribution and cooperating in collecting and recycling bottles, with the brewers' association acting as a third party.
When examining competitors as possible partners, Omri Gefen recommends a simple mapping by interests and influence: prefer competitors with whom there is more shared interest than conflict, and who have greater influence. As in any collaboration, the leading question is the potential value, and history and the relationship between the parties are not ignored.
Does coopetition exist inside the organization too?
Definitely. Units in the same organization compete for resources, headcount, budgets, bonuses and management's appreciation, and are required at the same time to cooperate. The research Omri Gefen cites shows that strong hierarchy and centralization harm sharing between competing units: "the more control is exerted on the units by headquarters, the less willing are the units to share information and knowledge between them". When there is less hierarchy and more informal relationships, there is more learning and sharing.
In his work with senior management teams and in complex processes within and between organizations, Omri Gefen sees that leaders with a systemic view and collaborative intelligence manage this paradox better. And if senior managers, especially the strongest among them, cling to preserving competition, it is almost impossible to implement collaboration. Managing such dual relationships also requires strong negotiation skills, which we expanded on in the article on negotiation management in complex organizations.
How to start in practice
It is worth mapping my competitors and asking a few honest questions.
With which competitor do I have more shared interests than I am willing to admit?
In which arena, far from the customer, could we cooperate without harming the competition we are in?
Who on my side is suited to lead the collaboration, and who should keep competing?
Which boundaries must I define in advance, legally as well, so that trust does not break?
And inside the organization: what are my units competing over, and does that competition serve the organization?
Frequently Asked Questions
What is coopetition?
A combination of cooperation and competition: a situation in which organizations or units compete with each other while cooperating at the same time in order to create value that none of them can create alone.
Is cooperation between competitors legal?
Yes, as long as it stays within the legitimate playing field and the legal boundaries. Omri Gefen emphasizes that this is not about creating cartels, and recommends defining in advance what stays out of the conversation.
How do you prevent competition from damaging the collaboration?
Through structural separation between the people and units that compete and those that cooperate. The further you are from the customer, the easier it is to cooperate.
Is coopetition relevant within an organization?
Yes. Units compete for resources and at the same time need to cooperate. Less hierarchy and more informal relationships increase sharing between them.
About the Author
Omri Gefen is a leading organizational consultant to CEOs and senior management teams. He founded Gevim Group and served as its CEO for more than two decades. He specializes in complex processes within and between organizations, including interfaces between the business, public, security and social sectors. His areas of expertise are collaboration, trust, negotiation, mediation and consensus building. He heads negotiation training in the Lahav Executive Program at Tel Aviv University, previously taught at Reichman University and Ben-Gurion University, and developed the Effective Collaboration Architecture (ECA) model. Omri Gefen is the author of "The Power of Collaboration: From Ego-System to Eco-System" (Routledge).
Organizations exploring cooperation with competitors, or managing internal competition between units, are welcome to learn about Omri Gefen's way of working on the consulting page of the website.